Get three bids on the same scope and a signed change order for every extra.
How to Negotiate With a Contractor on a Repair or Remodel Quote
To negotiate with a contractor, get written bids from three licensed contractors on the same written scope of work, compare them line by line, and ask the one you prefer which lines can move. Trade scope, materials or timing for price. Keep the deposit small, tie each later payment to finished work, and put every change in a signed change order before that work starts.
A contractor’s price is built from labor, materials, permits, overhead and margin. Most of what you can change is your decision: what gets built, which materials go in, who buys them and when the job starts. The FTC’s advice is to get multiple estimates, to avoid choosing the lowest bidder automatically, and to ask for an explanation if there is a big difference among them.
This page covers the FTC’s Cooling-Off Rule and the rules in California, New York State, New York City and Florida, as checked on November 20, 2026. Other states and many cities have their own licensing and contract rules. It is general information, and it does not give legal advice.
- Write down the scope of work: the job, the materials and finishes, who buys what and who pulls the permits.
- Check each contractor’s license with your state or local licensing office, and ask for proof of insurance.
- Get written bids from three contractors on that same scope, with labor, materials, permits and allowances on separate lines.
- Ask the contractor you prefer which lines can move, and offer scope, materials or timing in exchange for price.
- Keep the deposit small and tie each later payment to a stage of work that is finished.
- Sign only a complete written contract, and put every change in a signed change order before that work starts.
- If the price goes up mid-job, ask for the reason, the supplier’s invoice and the contract clause before you agree to anything.
The situation
Three bids for the same bathroom rarely compare cleanly. One includes tearing out the old tile and hauling it away; another leaves that to you. One prices a specific tile, and another carries an allowance, a sum set aside for something you will pick later. A low allowance makes a bid look cheaper than the finished job will be.
So before you talk price, make the bids describe the same job. Write the scope yourself: the work, the materials with brand, model, color and quantity where it matters, who buys what, who pulls the permits, and whether cleanup and haul-away are included. California’s licensing board gives the example of a contract that reads “install oak kitchen cabinets, manufactured by Company XYZ, model 01381A, as per the plan,” where a vague one says only “install kitchen cabinets.” Send that same page to every contractor and ask for a price line by line. The FTC says a written estimate should include a description of the work to be done, materials, completion date, and the price.
Your Plan B is the second bid you would actually sign, on the same scope. It tells the contractor you prefer what the job costs elsewhere, and they can check a written bid against their own lines in a way they cannot check a number you mention in passing.
Ask which lines have room, and bring things you can trade: a simpler finish, fixtures you buy yourself, cleanup you do, a start date that fits a gap in their calendar. Each of those lowers the contractor’s own cost, which makes a lower price easier for them to agree to.
Settle the payment schedule before you sign as well. A small deposit and payments tied to finished stages keep more of your money on your side until the work is done, and several states write limits on this into law. The FTC says don’t pay the full amount for the project up front, and never make the final payment until the work is done and you’re satisfied with it.
One job, from bids to final payment
Bids and the contract
Compare written bids on the same scope; settle the price, the scope and the payment schedule.
Signing
A small deposit. If you signed at home, a short right to cancel usually starts here.
During the job
Each payment after the stage it pays for is finished; a signed change order before any extra work.
The end
The final payment, as the contract sets it, after a walkthrough and any required inspections.
THE SCOPE (the same page goes to every contractor) Work to be done: [ ] Materials and finishes (brand, model, color, quantity): [ ] Who buys what (contractor / you): [ ] Demolition, haul-away and cleanup: [included / not included] Who pulls the permits: [ ] THIS BID Contractor: [ ] License number: [ ], checked with [state or city office] on [date] Proof of insurance seen: [yes / no] Labor: [$ ] Materials: [$ ] Allowances (item and amount): [ ] Permits and fees: [$ ] Total: [$ ] Left out of this bid: [ ] Start date and completion date: [ ] Deposit asked: [$ ] Payment schedule (amount, and the finished stage it pays for): [ ] Written warranty on labor: [ ] If material prices rise: [what the bid says] YOUR NUMBERS Plan B (the second bid you would sign): [contractor, $ ] Target price for this bid: [$ ] What you can trade: [finish, fixtures you buy, cleanup, start date] BEFORE YOU SIGN THE CONTRACT [ ] Contractor’s name, address, phone number and license number [ ] The work and the materials, described specifically enough to check [ ] Total price, the deposit and a payment schedule tied to stages of work [ ] Start date and completion date [ ] Who gets the permits [ ] Cleanup and haul-away [ ] Any warranty, in writing [ ] How changes are handled: a written change order with the price and the schedule effect, signed before the work [ ] What happens if material prices rise [ ] A notice of your right to cancel, if you signed at home [ ] Every promise made in conversation, written in [ ] No blank spaces
For a home repair or remodel in the US. State law may require more in the contract than this list.
What to say to the contractor
- I’m getting three bids on the same scope, and here it is in writing. Can you price it line by line, with labor, materials, permits and any allowances on separate lines?
- What does this allowance cover, and what happens if what I pick costs more?
- Your bid is [$X] and another bid on the same scope is [$Y]. Can you walk me through which lines make up the difference?
- Which of these lines have room in them?
- If I [buy the fixtures myself / do the cleanup / am flexible on the start date], what does that do to the price?
- I’d like the deposit at [$ ] and each payment after the stage it pays for is finished. Can we write the schedule that way?
- Before I sign: what happens if a material price goes up before you order it? I’d like the answer written into the contract.
- Can you write that up as a change order first, with the price and what it does to the schedule? I’ll read it, and if it works for me I’ll sign it before you start on it.
- You said the [material] went up. Can you send me the supplier’s invoice and show me the part of our contract that covers a price change?
- Before I agree to anything, what else could we do? Could you use a different [material] at the old price, or could I buy it myself? Or could you order the rest now so the price can’t move again?
Small, with every later payment tied to work that is finished
No federal rule sets a home improvement deposit; the FTC says don’t pay the full amount up front and that some states limit the down payment. In California, the down payment cannot be more than $1,000 or 10 percent of the contract price, whichever is less, with no exception for special-order materials, and later payments cannot exceed the value of the work done and materials delivered. In New York City, the consumer agency DCWP advises paying no more than 25 percent of the total upfront. In New York State, on a home improvement job over $500, payments made before the job is substantially complete must go into an escrow account at a New York bank, unless the contractor gives you a bond or similar guarantee. In Florida, a contractor who takes more than 10 percent of the contract price as the first payment must apply for any needed permits within 30 days and start work within 90 days after they are issued, unless there is just cause or you agreed in writing to a longer period. Elsewhere, check your state attorney general’s or licensing board’s page. Checked November 20, 2026.
Check the license and insurance first
The FTC advises considering only contractors who are licensed and insured, confirming the license with your state or county government, and asking the contractor for proof of insurance. Do it before you negotiate. A bid from someone who can’t legally do the job is no use as a Plan B.
In California, a contractor needs a license from the Contractors State License Board (CSLB) for a job of $1,000 or more in labor and materials, and for a smaller job that needs a building permit or where the person employs workers. That threshold rose from $500 on January 1, 2025. You can check a license on the CSLB website.
In New York City, a business needs a Home Improvement Contractor license from the Department of Consumer and Worker Protection (DCWP) to do work costing more than $200 on a residential building. Check it by calling 311 or at nyc.gov/dcwp. If you hire an unlicensed contractor, you are not eligible for repayment from the city’s Home Improvement Contractor Trust Fund, which can repay consumers when a licensed contractor did not finish the job or owes them money.
In Florida, the Department of Business and Professional Regulation (DBPR) has a license search on its website. A Florida contract for work on a home where labor and materials come to more than $2,500 must include a written notice about the Florida Homeowners’ Construction Recovery Fund.
The deposit and the payment schedule
A payment schedule lists each payment and the work it pays for. Ask for one where each payment follows a stage you can see finished, such as demolition done, tile set or fixtures installed, with the last payment after a final walkthrough. That keeps what you have paid close to the value of the work in your house. Once the schedule is signed, pay each stage as the contract says. Holding back a payment the contract requires can turn into a claim against you, and in California and New York an unpaid contractor may be able to make a lien claim against your home.
In California, the down payment on a home improvement contract cannot be more than $1,000 or 10 percent of the contract price, whichever is less, excluding finance charges, and CSLB says there are no exceptions for special-order materials. If the contract has payments due before the work is finished, it must include a schedule of those payments tied to the work and materials, and apart from the down payment, no payment can exceed the value of the work performed or material delivered. A handful of contractors with a blanket performance and payment bond on file with CSLB are exempt; the license check shows whether yours has one.
Also in California, an unpaid subcontractor or supplier can record a mechanics lien on your home even if you have paid the contractor in full. CSLB suggests getting a list of the subcontractors and suppliers, having subcontractors sign lien releases when their part of the work is finished, and paying with a joint check made out to the contractor and the subcontractor or supplier.
In New York State, according to the state Attorney General, on a home improvement job costing more than $500, payments made before the job is substantially complete must be put into a trust (escrow) account at a New York bank within five business days, and you must be told where the money is held within ten business days, unless the contractor gives you a bond or contract of indemnity. Progress payments must bear a reasonable relationship to the work done, materials bought or other costs. In New York City, DCWP advises paying no more than 25 percent of the total upfront.
In Florida, a contractor who receives more than 10 percent of the contract price as the first payment for work on a home must apply for the necessary permits within 30 days and start the work within 90 days after the permits are issued, unless there is just cause or you agreed in writing to a longer period.
Change orders: every change in writing first
Plans change once the walls are open. A change order is a short written addition to the contract: what the extra work is, what it adds to or takes off the price, and what it does to the payment schedule and the finish date. Ask for one and read it. If you agree, sign it before the work starts; if you don’t, the work doesn’t start. Keep every signed change order with the contract.
In California, CSLB says the job must be completed for the agreed-upon contract price, and any change to the price has to be made with a written change order that becomes part of the contract. A change order is not enforceable against the homeowner unless, before the work begins, it sets out in writing the scope of the work, the amount added to or subtracted from the contract, and its effect on the progress payments or the completion date. A contractor who skipped that paperwork can still seek payment for work actually done, so the written order protects both of you.
In other states, read what your contract says about changes before you sign, and if it says nothing, ask for a clause. Get Ahead of the change you can see coming at the bid stage: ask what happens if a material price rises before it is ordered, and have the answer written in.
If the contractor finds the paperwork a nuisance, say it for them: “It sounds like stopping to write this up slows you down.” That is Labeling. Let them answer, then ask for the order in writing anyway.
When the price goes up mid-job
When a contractor says materials went up, start with the contract. A fixed-price contract sets the price for the work it describes. Some contracts include a clause that lets the price change if material costs rise, and some don’t. Ask which part of the contract they are relying on, and for the supplier’s invoice or quote showing the old price and the new one.
If the contract has no such clause, say so calmly and ask how they plan to finish at the agreed price. If it does, or if you would rather keep the job moving, the increase is something to negotiate like the original bid: a substitute material at the old price, you buying the material directly, ordering the rest of the materials now so the price can’t move again, or sharing the increase. Whatever you agree goes into a signed change order before the work continues.
In California, the job must be completed for the agreed contract price unless a written change order changes it. In Florida, a contractor who has received more money than the value of the work done may not stop work for any 90-day period, or a period set in the contract, without just cause; the statute’s first step for the homeowner is a written demand sent by certified mail, return receipt requested.
Your right to cancel after signing
Under the FTC’s Cooling-Off Rule, if you sign a contract for $25 or more at your home, you generally have until midnight of the third business day after the sale to cancel, without giving a reason, and the seller must refund your payments within 10 business days of receiving your notice. Saturday counts as a business day; Sundays and federal holidays do not. The rule applies even when you invited the contractor to your home. The contractor has to give you a cancellation form and tell you about the right when you sign. To cancel, sign and date the form, or write a letter if you didn’t get one; the FTC suggests sending it by certified mail and keeping a copy.
The rule does not cover a sale you finished negotiating at the seller’s permanent place of business, or a visit you asked for to repair or maintain your personal property (anything extra you buy on that visit is covered). It also excludes a genuine emergency where you made the first contact and gave the seller a separate signed, handwritten statement describing the emergency and waiving the right to cancel.
Some states give more. In California, if you sign a home improvement contract of $25 or more anywhere other than the contractor’s place of business, you can cancel it in writing within three business days, five if you are 65 or older, and seven for repairs to a home damaged in a disaster for which a state of emergency was declared. If you signed at the contractor’s place of business, this right does not apply. The exception is a small service and repair contract: $750 or less, for work you contacted the contractor to do, with nothing extra sold and no payment due until the job is finished. For that kind of contract, the right to cancel ends once you have a signed copy and the work has started (Business and Professions Code 7159.10).
In New York State, you can cancel a home improvement contract by written notice until midnight of the third business day after you sign it. The exception is an emergency you called the contractor about, and only if you also signed a separate handwritten statement giving up the right to cancel.
If it goes wrong: where to complain
Start with the contractor, in writing. The FTC suggests confirming phone conversations with a letter sent by certified mail with a return receipt, and keeping notes and copies of everything. If that doesn’t settle it, the FTC points you to your state attorney general or local consumer protection office.
In California, you can file a complaint with CSLB, which handles violations of contractor law for up to four years from the date of the act. A CSLB investigation can lead to discipline against the contractor. CSLB says its investigations are not meant to recover money, and it points consumers who want money back to the courts, including small claims for smaller amounts. In New York City, call 311 or go to nyc.gov/dcwp to report a contract or quality-of-work dispute. In Florida, DBPR takes complaints about licensed contractors. You can report a scam to the FTC at ReportFraud.ftc.gov. For a dispute over money, small claims court is another route, and its limits vary by state. Check your state’s official page for your own case, and talk to a lawyer about a large or complicated one.
How it sounds
An illustrative bathroom remodel with round numbers. The homeowner sent the same written scope to three licensed contractors and got bids of $18,400, $15,900 and $16,700. The $18,400 contractor is the one they want: good references, and the crew can start next month.
Why this works: Saying why you want this contractor comes first, then the two other numbers, then a question about the lines that differ, which the contractor can answer one line at a time.
The contractor looks at the lines.
Why this works: This is Mirroring on the number, followed by Silence. Repeating it asks the contractor to explain it. In this example he offered a porcelain at $2,000 that looks close, which took the bid to $17,200.
The homeowner asks for a little more.
Why this works: When the job gets smaller, the contractor can lower the price and keep their margin. Before you agree, ask how their warranty treats fixtures you supply.
The price is settled. The contractor turns to payment.
Why this works: Paying for materials when they arrive covers the contractor’s real cost without paying for work that hasn’t started. In California the law sets this limit anyway: $1,000 or 10 percent of the price, whichever is less, with no exception for special-order materials.
Three weeks into the job, the contractor calls.
Why this works: Labeling the contractor’s problem acknowledges it, and you have still agreed to nothing. The invoice shows what changed and by how much, and the contract shows whether a price change is allowed. Anything you agree goes into a signed change order before the work continues.
What not to say
Do not open with your budget. A budget said first can become the Anchor the bid is built around. Contractors often say a budget helps them design, and for a custom job it does. So hand over the written scope first and ask for their price on it. If they still need a figure to design to, give a range and say what it has to cover.
Do not invent a lower bid. The contractor’s next question is what that bid includes, and you can’t answer that for a bid that doesn’t exist.
Do not push for a lower total with nothing traded. A cut the contractor cannot afford can come back later as cheaper materials or a run of change orders. Trade something real, or ask which lines have room.
Do not pay a large deposit, and do not pay in cash. The FTC lists asking you to pay for everything up front, or accepting only cash, among the signs of a home improvement scam, along with pressure for an immediate decision and a knock on the door from someone who says they are “in the area.”
Do not agree to extra work with a nod on site. “While the wall’s open, I can move that outlet” is a change to the contract. Ask for it as a written change order with its price before the work starts.
Do not sign a contract with blank spaces. California’s licensing board says never to sign a blank or partially blank contract, because once you sign, you and the contractor are both bound by what it says.
Try it against someone who pushes back
Rehearse a seller who opens highPro scenario · sign up free to read the brief, play the session with Pro · a seller who opens high and expects you to leave
Common mistakes
- Comparing bids that describe different jobs. Send every contractor the same written scope, and check what each bid leaves out and how big each allowance is.
- Giving your budget before you have a price.
- Asking for a lower price with nothing to trade.
- Hiring before checking the license and seeing proof of insurance.
- Paying a large deposit, or paying in cash.
- Agreeing to extra work out loud on site, with no written change order.
- Making the final payment before the work is finished and you have checked it.
Questions people ask
Can you negotiate a contractor’s quote?
Yes, in the US a contractor’s quote for a home repair or remodel is open to discussion before you sign: the price, the scope, the materials, the timing and the payment schedule. Get written bids from several licensed contractors on the same written scope, ask the one you prefer which lines have room, and trade something real, such as a simpler finish, fixtures you buy yourself or a flexible start date, for a lower price. The FTC advises against automatically choosing the lowest bidder and suggests asking for an explanation when bids differ widely.
How much deposit should a contractor get?
No federal rule sets a home improvement deposit in the US; in California the down payment can’t exceed $1,000 or 10 percent of the contract price, whichever is less, and New York City’s consumer agency, DCWP, advises paying no more than 25 percent up front. In New York State, on a home improvement job over $500, payments made before the job is substantially complete must be held in escrow at a New York bank unless the contractor gives you a bond or similar guarantee. In Florida, a contractor who takes more than 10 percent of the price as the first payment must apply for any needed permits within 30 days and start within 90 days after they are issued, unless there is just cause or you agreed in writing to a longer period. The FTC says not to pay the full amount up front. Checked November 20, 2026.
Should I tell a contractor my budget?
For a US home repair or remodel, give the contractor your written scope first and ask for their price on it, then share a budget range if they need one to design to. A budget said before any price can become the figure the bid is built around. Once you have bids on the same scope, telling the contractor you prefer what you can spend helps them suggest which lines to change.
What should I say when a contractor says materials went up mid-job?
On a US home repair or remodel, ask before you agree to anything: which part of the contract allows a price change, and can they send the supplier’s invoice showing the old and new price. If the contract allows it, negotiate the increase like the original bid, with a substitute material, materials you buy directly or the rest ordered now so the price can’t move again. Put any agreement in a signed change order before the work continues. In California, the job must be completed for the agreed contract price unless a written change order changes it.
Can I cancel a contract with a contractor after signing?
In the US, the FTC’s Cooling-Off Rule generally gives you until midnight of the third business day to cancel a sale of $25 or more made at your home, including a contract signed at your kitchen table after a contractor’s visit, even if you invited them. It doesn’t cover a sale you finished negotiating at the seller’s permanent place of business, a repair visit you asked for on your personal property, or an emergency where you signed a handwritten waiver. Some states give more: in California, for a home improvement contract signed away from the contractor’s place of business, you have three business days, five if you are 65 or older, and seven for repairs after a declared emergency. Cancel in writing and keep a copy.
Sources
Practice the real thing
The techniques this uses
Drill it until it’s a reflex
Rehearse a seller who opens highPro scenario · sign up free to read the brief, play the session with Pro · a seller who opens high and expects you to leave